Home | October 2005 >>

Hitting the high notes

Joel has written another (very funny) impassioned article about the benefits of hiring superstar programmers

Wiki, blog and web cms convergence

Eric Burke writes that the line is blurring between blog software, wikis, discussion forums and CMS tools.

We use confluence extensively at work, fantastic tool.. The line between this tool and a low end web-cms is certainly blurring. As an example, the penrose website is published on confluence and looks just like an ordinary (and quite clean) website - the wiki functionality is carefully hidden out of the way.

It seems to me confluence just needs a few things to achieve the convergence Eric talks about..

First, many (most?) wiki tools have pages are shelved in folder locations rather than using permalinks -- but in the web world there is no shelf. Tools like pebble use the 'category' concept rather than a folder. A blog entry can appear in many categories but a wiki page can appear in only one folder.

Second, I look forward to the day when Radeox engines based wikis provide a wysiwig editor as an alternative so I can give confluence to wider groups of lay users. The jotspot service apparently offers this on their blog.

Third, the blogging (news) functions in confluence seem tacked on.. It is far from good enough (yet) to replace pebble for blogging. Also, I would want to see tight integration between blog/wiki content items. Maybe a blog entrys should automatically appear as wiki pages..

And the winner is...

My requirements for a blogging tool are that is runs in Tomcat, supports radeox wiki syntax, looks nice out of the box, can be skinned and is easy to admin. The software that meets all these things is pebble…